Dosto sab se pehley aap sab ko Gandhi Jayanti ki Khub Khub Subhkaamnaaye. Aaj Hum Mahatma Gandhi ke baare main baat karengey lekin kuch aise baat karengey jo shaayad aapko na pata ho. Aapne Gandhiji ke Jivan ke baare main bahut saari cheeze padhi hongi ya suni hogi lekin aaj jo main aapko bataane jaa raha hu woh shaayad hi aapne padha ho ya suna na ho.



Dost Mahatma Gandhi bahut bhadiya social activist they, aur kaafi inspiring leader they. Lekin unhone kuch galtiya ki thi aur un main kuch khaamiya thi jo kaafi logo ko nahi pata.

Dosto Post thora lamba ho jaayga lekin main aapse request karta hu ki please poora padhyega.

Aur dusri baat dosto yeh ki yeh main apne mann se apne hisaab se nahi likh raha hu poora research kar ke main likh raha hu, aur mere dil main Mahatma Gandhi ko lekar bahut izaat hai. Aur main is post main sirf yeh hi cover karunga ki kaise smart logo ne Gandhi ko criticize kiya, kyoun ki kya hai bahut saare bewakoof log hai jo Gandhi ko stupid reasons ke wajah se hate kartey hai jaise woh movie aayi thi"The Legend of Bhagat Singh" kyoun ki woh bhagat singh ko bacha nahi sake matlab woh galat they.

Dosto hum baat karengey,


  • Criticism of Gandhi's ideology.
  • Criticism of Gandhi's actions.
  • Indirect consequences of Gandhi's actions.
  • Conclusion



Toh start kartey hai :)

Criticism of Gandhi's ideology.

Mahatma Gandhi ki ideology kya hai? Non-violent resistance, poorn svatantrata, aatmanirbharata aur samaanata. Saare kaafi acche ideas they aur kaam ke they. Lekin kuch unkahi baatein bhi hai Gandhi ki ideology ke baare main jo main aapko bataaunga.

Yaha kuch example main likh raha hu jo main aapko bataane jaa raha hu.

1927 main Mahatma Gandhi ne C. Rajagopalchari ke baare main yeh bataatey huey kaha ki "I do say he is the only possible successor" matlab ki Rajaji hi sirf uttaraadhikaaree ban saktey hai, yaha per yeh baat saaf ho jaati hai ki us wqat Gandhi g ke yeh kaafi favorite they. lekin phir inke bich main 1942 main Cripss commission ko lekar disagreement hua, toh Rajaji congress se bahaar.

Aur phir Gandhi g ne kaha,

"Not Rajaji, but Jawaharlal Nehru will be my successor" samjhe aap? ki Rajaji nahi Jawaharlal Nehru uttaraadhikaaree ke liye laayak hai.

Iska matlab yeh hua ki Rajaji jaisa great rajneta sirf ek governor jabki Nehru ne India ki sab se ahem post ko occupy kar liya.

Ek aur example, log chaatey they ki Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose Indain National Congress se resign ker de aur party se dur chale jaaye actually us waqt hua yeh tha ki 1938 main Netaji INC ke president baney us waqt Gandhi g Pattabhi Sitaramayya ko support kar rahe they dosto yeh ek lambi aur lag story hai is liye is pe main baat nahi karunga, lekin Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ne us waqt Congress se resign Gandhi g ke wajah se hi kiya.

Aur yeh examples koi alag examples nahi hai, Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel ki jagha Jawahrlal Nehur ko chunna unhe zyaada preference dena yeh saare Gaandhi g kee taanaashaahee pravrttiyaan thi.

Aur kahi na kahi yeh lagta hai ki Gandhi g Gandhism ko theek se explain nahi kar paaye. Kuch logo ko lagta hai apne aapko surrender karna yeh Gandhism hai. Aur aise logo ka haal Sri Lanka ke Rasaiah Prathipan jaisa hota hai yeh hunger strike kar ke mar gaye lekin sarkar ne uski nahi suni.

Yeh science aur technology ke bhi virodhi they inka maana tha yeh ek satanic cheez hai, Woh apni ideology main itne doob gaye they ki woh chaatey toh apni wife ko bacha saktey they lekin unhone apni wife ko marne diya unhone unko injection nahi lene diya kyoun ki unke hisaab se injections kaafi violent hotey hai. (Aap padh saktey hai Freedom at Midnight per)

Ek politican ko apni ideology ke saath kabhi kabaar compromise karna chiyeh. example ke liye Abraham Lincoln kaamyab rahe they Liberal Rebpublicans, conservative republican aur radical republicans ko manaane main ki aap sab ko saath main kaam karna hai jabki yeh ek dusre ke virodhi they. Gandhi g aisa kyoun nahi kar paaye?

Criticism of Gandhi's actions

Kuch movements kaafi acche kiye Gandhi g ne jaise Champaran and Kheda aur Salt Satyagrah, lekin mujhe problem hai Non-Cooperation movement and Quit India Movement se.

1 - Non-Coopation - Yeh idea ek story jaisa laga lekin isko kaafi success mila. Aur British isse kaafi darr gaye ki ab toh India humaare haath se gaya. Lekin inko itna bhi darr nahi tha kyoun ki inhe pata tha ki Gandhi g main yeh talent hai ki jo movements unhone itna lad lad ke kaamyab kiya hai woh unhe ek pal main hi barbaad kar saktey hai.

Hua kya ki Chauri Chaura incident ki wajah se inhone is movemnt ko bandh kar diya. 

The Largest Independece movement in history was called off beacuse of his idealism.

Aur dukhad baat yaha yeh hai ki Gandhi g ne try bhi nahi kari apne followes ko samjhaane ki ke waapas se ek peaceful tarike se protest karey Non-cooperation movement main lekin Gandhi g is cheez main fail huey. Aur iske baad kya hua pata hai aapko?

19 logo ko phaasi hui, 110 logo ko Umar ked hui, aur 6 log police custody main hi mar gaye.

2 - Quit India Movement

Yeh sab se kharaab movement tha yeh mera maana hai. Speech acchi thi lekin speech ke alaava kuch accha nahi tha. Start toh kaafi acchi intentions se kiya tha, lekin end main iss movement ne eendhan ka kaam kiya partition karwaane main. Kaafi logo ne is movement ko support nahi kiya.

Communist party ne iska jam ke virodh kiya kyoun ki woh Soviet Union ko support kar rahe they. Muslim leaders ne toh poori tahra se virodh kiya, jiske wajah se Muslim League ko British ke saath deal karni padhi. Aur kehne lagey,

"We will support you in the war provided you support us in our bid for partition" [ab yeh kisne kaha yeh hum exactly nahi keh saktey]

Lekin aisa movement karna hi kyoun ki jis main kaafi saare logo ki jaan jaaye. Quit India movement ki dauran INC bhi banned thi, aur kaafi bade leaders ko arrest kiya gaya, iske baad kai logo ne ek hi mantra apna liya "maro ya maaro" kaafi saare goverment office jala diye gaye, building jala diye gaye, railways tracks ko damage kiya gaya kafi kuch hua iss movement main.

Aur lathi charge kiya gaya, firing ki gayi, sekdo logo ko arrest kiya gaya kaha jaata 60,000 logo ko jail main daal diya gaya Quit India Movement ke dauran, hazaaro logo mar gaye.

Aur yeh saare incident ki wajah se (Aur bhi kai wajah thi) Muslim leage ka uday kaafi jabardast tarike se hua.

Kaafi congress leader ka sochna tha ki partition unavoidable hai log chaatey hai ki partition ho. Lekin aisa kyoun? Jab Southern States United states se alag hua, Abraham Lincoln ne yeh nahi kaha ki bhai yeh hi accha hai, nahi balki inhone kya kiya yeh lade war kiya aur Union ko sambhaal ke rakkha. Toh Gandhi g aisa kyoun na kar sake? Shaayda ahimsa se wajah se.z

Indirect consequences of Gandhi's Actions:

Common knowledge hai ki Gandhi, Patel, Nehru aur Rajaji ko kam kathor saza mili dusre teztaraar activist ke muqaable. Ab iska matlab yeh nahi ki yeh chaaro ne kam saha ho. Inhone ne bhi kaafi saha hai, lekin in logo ko fair trail bhi miley they jo dusre activist ko nahi miley.

Fazl-e-haq, Khairabadi, Yogendra Shukla, Batukeshwar Dutt, Maulana Ahmdullah, jaise krantikaaryoun ko Jail main daal diya gaya.

Nehru g Gandhi ki vinaashkari economic principle and defense se kaafi prabhaavit they, for example Nehru G ne refuse kar diya ki Indain Army ko kisi bhi tahra ki air strike sahayta nahi milegy.

Conclusion:

Jaise main starting main kaha Gandhi g main kaafi izzat karta hu, unhone Britisho ke khilaaf kaafi acche se lada. Main inhe ek great social worker maanta hu lekin jaha tak politics ki baat aati hai yeh ek weak politician they apni idealism ki wajha se.

Aapke koi bhi sujhaav ho comment ki zariyeh aap mujhe pata saktey hai. Thanks